2. Sean is making an argument.
Premise:
The criminal mind cannot be rehabilitated.
Conclusion:
The criminal mind cannot be rehabilitated.
Explanation：
This is a circular argument. Sean claims that those who have been completely rehabilitated never have had truly criminal mind so the criminal mind cannot be rehabilitated. But the essence of “those who have been completely rehabilitated never have had truly criminal mind” is “those who have truly criminal mind cannot be rehabilitated”, which cannot serve as evidence.
4.Dorothy is making an argument.
Premise:
The Timothy, one chapter of Bible says that all scripture is given by inspiration of God.
Conclusion: Bible is the inspired word of God.
Explanation: It is a circular argument. Dorothy claims that Bible is the inspired word of God because Bible says Bible is the inspired word of God. This is just another claim,not evidence.
